Think once for “yes” and twice for “no”

BBC News yesterday ran a terrifying article about scientists successfully communicating with people who are apparently in persistent vegetative states.

The idea is straightforward enough.  The scientists told an apparently non-responsive man to imagine playing tennis if he wanted to indicate “yes,” and to imagine walking empty streets if he wanted to indicate “no.”  They then scanned his brain while asking him questions, and read his answers off of the different patters of activity.  Using this technique, he was able to answer biographical questions about himself.  (He got five of six right.)

If this research is confirmed, I assume it will have immediate practical implications in bioethics.  It’s typically legal to withhold life-support from patients in persistent vegetative states.  But surely this approach should be changed if we’re over-diagnosing PVS.

This case is also a great way to motivate the physicalism/substance dualism debate in the classroom.  Here we have someone answering questions from what was previously thought to be a vegetative state.  Is this better characterized as evidence that the mind can be trapped inside a malfunctioning brain?  Or that mental processes are brain processes, and that a partial failure of the brain implies a partial failure of the mind?

Related articles:

Defining Physicalism
By Alyssa Ney , University of Rochester
(Vol. 3, July 2008)
Philosophy Compass

2 thoughts on “Think once for “yes” and twice for “no””

  1. I’m really glad you referred to this as terrifying. When I originally read the article I was baffled by the lack of any mention about what the hell they were planning on doing to let the apparently lucid people previously thought to be vegetative communicate with the rest of the world as soon as humanly possible. The thought of them being effectively trapped in their paralysed bodies for years on end completely freaked me out – but apparently not the reporter, or, seemingly, the researchers.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: